Recent incidences of violence, in India, have left me
shattered and filled me with shame. While my conscience is clear and the stand
of my immediate family (I say immediate family because there are “Sanghis” in
my family too) is a balanced one, it is a fact that a rank outsider may very
well, judge me just on the fact that I am a Hindu.
I am not a Hindu, I do not want to be a Hindu; me being a
Hindu is just a birth lottery, an event on which I had zero control.
Looking at my nation today, I have every reason to feel
ashamed of being a Hindu.
I am tired of the endless questions, challenges and
justifications that keep pouring with alarming frequency and with increasing
absurdity. It appears that the only arsenal left in this argument is to present
yourself so absolutely irrational, that a counter-argument is just not
possible, to even form, let alone be taken to fruition.
Life should be defined “in the now”. Your life is what
you are living right now. The acts that you commit, has an impact on your life
and the lives of others, depending on the influence you wield, in the present, and
in many instances how the future acts are shaped.
Remember your history, else you will have to repeat it is
indeed a strong guiding principle if and only if
this is practiced towards making a better present and a more meaningful future.
If we are going to remember history with a singular purpose of exacting
revenge, right the (perceived and real) wrongs and to shape or alter it to fit
our narrative to achieve our end goal, it is meaningless to me. I would rather
forget my history, not care to even understand who killed who, when, how many,
how and so on.
The current state of lawlessness and the brazen display of the “who-can-touch-me” attitude being put on clearly for the world to see is
alarming and disgusting in equal measure. Each election is fought on divisive
platforms. It is always putting one against the other. Not economy, not
improvements, not employments, not infrastructure, not agriculture. Just a
simple brutal one vs another. Hindu Muslim sits at the very top. Followed by,
upper-caste vs lower caste, lower caster vs scheduled castes, scheduled castes
vs tribal, farmer vs city dweller, people marked with their ethnography, where
they hail from, what they eat, …. Not one issue worth it's salt. When I watch
such election rallies and the issues on which the elections are fought, I am
left dumbstruck. That people would not cringe uttering such sheer lunatic
ramblings stun me.
Politics has become a four-letter word, not just in India,
but the world over, thanks to the rise of right-wing nationalism, slowly and
steadily. Like every known form of cancer. And as in cancer, there is no cure.
While every party is deplorable, with its myopia and self-serving agenda, my greatest
regret, anger, fury, disgust, helplessness, frustration and total disrespect is
reserved entirely towards one party.
The BJP.
Founded on the distorted ideologies of RSS and been
in the sidelines of the political field for long periods, the bigot filled
party rose on the Hindu Muslim agenda and rode to power. The mothership, RSS
itself is an aberration and would have been banned in any country that values
human lives and morals. RSS had been banned in India on more than one occasion.
But, like a weed that keeps sprouting in your garden, parasitically sucking the
nutrients of the other plants, killing them in the long run, the organization
which is an insult to any human being with a modicum of intelligence and
self-respect kept coming back to life. Like the patch of the garden that is
not attended to in time, the few saplings of weed had grown and engulfed the
entire garden, leaving the place only for the Lotus!
The rise of BJP, and the associated Hindutva, is not so much
an accomplishment of its own. It is more a degeneration of the only meaningful
opponent it ever had, the Indian National Congress. The Congress party that
fought for the freedom, that stood for secularism lost its mantle, the meaning, and character, gradually, steadily over a long-drawn period. The initial
euphoria of freedom soon died, and the slow and steady decline of congress
had many reasons. I am listing here the important ones in my reckoning
·
Socialism (instead of competitive capitalism,
this defeated all the good intentions and gave a false sense of security and
encouraged protectionism while the world was growing rapidly)
·
Bureaucracy
·
Nepotism – (Converting Congress into a
Gandhi-Nehru dynasty)
·
Corruption
·
Pseudo-secularism (If the BJP, my main target in
this blog is guilty of blatant Hindutva, Congress encouraged selective
appeasement with only the vote bank in mind)
·
Complacency
Even the brilliant turnaround of the flailing Indian economy
engineered by the eminent stalwarts like Manmohan Singh and Ahluwalia under the
helm of the most underrated, unacknowledged Prime Minister of India, P V
Narasimha Rao, could not save the congress from the eventual capitulation. As
the Congress party failed to control nepotism (Robert Vadra, just the tip of an
enormous iceberg, that sank the Titanic called Congress) and rampant
corruption, even an unblemished, beyond reproach Mr. Singh could not save the
congress. When the need of the hour was for a leader of excellent leadership
and spotless track record, all they could come up with was, a Rahul Gandhi. A
man so unbelievably asinine, even a scripted role of a village idiot would fail
against him. It is like the slaves languishing under the Pharaoh waiting for
their messiah to get a clown who hopes to entertain them with an inept act of
juggling.
The less said about him, the better.
The British ruled India for upwards of 200 years. This came
to pass, among other things, mainly due to a singular fact – lack of unity
between many warring factions. Brits found this a fertile ground and invented
divide and rule.
BJP, in the 21st century was offered the same
conditions to flourish, on a silver platter with watercresses around it (as PG
Wodehouse would have said), by various regional parties who could not muster up
a nationwide opposition or a combined party of any substance. The communist
party ruled just two states, the regional parties ruled many states and the
only meaningful opposition, if one could call the crumbling Congress that, was
Congress. Congress was no match to BJP at this stage. And predictably the Congress
was routed in two successive elections and the nemesis of India, the BJP
stormed to power. The reason I hate BJP is it is communal and divisive. Among
the many arsenals of the BJP, its topmost strengths(!) are
· It lies – unashamedly, brazenly, with not a care
about any documented evidence
· Rules through fear
· Has no morals
· Anti-Muslim
Let us go over them one by one.
Lies:
No other organization or its leaders lie as much as BJP or
Narendra Modi does. And the sheer hypocrisy is even more stunning. They have at
their disposal, a great army of IT cell operators, their rabid followers
(called Bhakts in India – meaning an obedient and blind follower) and bought
media to propagate and foster their lies. BJP has taken lying as an art to a
level till date never experienced. Normal people care a little while lying as
there is no shame greater than to be caught having lied. People in public light
are expected to be extra vigilant, simply because they are in the public light.
In today’s digital world, everything you ever said is captured somewhere and
stored for eternity. It does not take too long to reproduce what someone said
on some topic at any given point in time.
Election manifesto as a form of a lie is not relevant
anymore. No one takes promises made in election manifesto seriously anymore.
(It is however, worth reminding here, that BJP had gone on and implemented most
of their farfetched fanatical commitments made, very much similar to Hitler and
Mein Kempf; no one took them seriously and by the time they did, it was already
too late) What makes BJP stand apart is their brazenness in lying after
the elections. They lie so openly and confidently, that an ordinary guy
who would like to question pauses to think, along these lines,” if he is saying
so confidently, would he be lying”.
George Orwell gave the world a completely new set of
vocabulary with his seminal work of dystopia “1984” and the most telling of
them is doublespeak. If someone had perfected the art of doublespeak, it is
BJP. They would win all the awards by a huge margin if there were to be a
competition on doublespeak. Claim that they do not differentiate based on
religion and implement a draconian law that excludes one religion. Claim that
they encourage dissent and transfer every official who does that. Claim that
they encourage dissent and quell the same with a ruthlessness that is outright
scary. Which government unleashes its own police force to squash a student
unrest? I had once mentioned in an earlier blogpost of mine, that India is the
only country where people are scared when a policeman approaches them. It is
still true. When police force with such a reputation is given carte
blanche, chaos follows every single time. (On an unrelated note, the police
killed four rape accused in a staged encounter after yet another brutal rape.
People celebrated and even garlanded the cops. The judiciary ordered an inquiry
commission, and no one remembers it now (just 4 months ago) as the country is
now under the grip of the Citizenship act and the pogrom that is ensuing)
Keep the people confused is their mantra. The recent case of
Modi and Shah’s stand on NRC is a sterling example.
(For those who do not follow Hindi, the prime minister says
that he or his government never even discussed NRC while his right-hand man,
the home minister says NRC will come, not just in Assam but all over India)
A sample is enough here as more eminent people like
Krish Ashok, Varun Grover, Sayantan Ghosh, Ujval and Rana Ayub have
exposed the lies of these two leaders (!) on numerous occasions.
Rules through fear:
What is indisputable today about India is that there is a
palpable sense of fear permeating every aspect of society. Walls have ears
is suddenly becoming a frightening reality. People are afraid to speak out.
Because if they do, they are hounded. Trolled mercilessly online, targeted
viciously, harmed physically and subjected to every scrutiny possible under
various departments at the disposal of the government. Few celebrities in the
past spoke about this “climate of fear” and paid a heavy price. Their films
were boycotted, they and their families were harassed, effigies were burnt,
their loyalty questioned, and they were given the extreme ultimatum by the
Bhakts and the government – in India, it is
“Go to Pakistan”. Anyone who
questions them must leave India. The discord is so deeply rooted in India, that
if you were to ask a school going child “What is the opposite of India”,
chances are the child will answer “Pakistan”.
As Ramachandra Guha pointed out recently, the institutes
that are meant to be independent and autonomous have all been compromised and
they live today in constant fear of the government and toe their line. The
institutes in question are, not exhaustive but representative of the rot that
had set in, the judiciary, the army, the police force, the election commission,
the media and the RBI (Reserve bank of India). When these institutes, who can
check an irresponsible government, are kept on a tight leash, what hopes can a
common man nurture? A stray, honest officer who breaks the line is immediately
transferred or arrested under seditious acts that give the police the privilege
to detain him/her endlessly without providing a reason.
Of all the compromised institutions, no one can hold a
candle to the media. Arnab Goswami is an insult to a human being!
Industrialists or public figures who dare to question the government are hounded by a battery of institutions, like the income tax,
foreign exchange regulatory, excise evasion, disproportionate asset inquiry ….
Rahul Bajaj, Naseeruddin Shah, Amir Khan, Shah Rukh Khan are
some of the names that come to mind who spoke up and paid a price. (or still
paying a price)
Another great weapon they have recently discovered, and are
putting to great use, is ban the internet! They do it so regularly that it
has become a norm now than an exception.
Has no morals:
· Sadhvi Pragya – terror accused – Member of
Parliament
· Kuldeep Singh Sengar – Member of parliament convicted of rape,
murder, attempt to murder, criminal conspiracy and criminal intimidation.
· Kapil Mishra – MLA – singularly to be held
responsible for the current crisis in Delhi which saw the worst unrest that had
claimed 38 lives (and counting)
· Yogi Adityanath – Hindutva Chief Minister of UP,
a state where police brutality has made even the Indian population go numb with
disbelief, who also made a speech during the recently concluded Delhi election
in which he said “If they do not understand words, they will understand bullets”
· Anurag Thakur – A minister of State, no less.
Who recently encouraged (a euphemism for whipping them to a blind frenzy) a
congregation of Bhakts to chant “Shoot the traitors”
· Amit Shah – Home Minister – Investigated for
murder
· Narendra Modi – During 2002 Gujrat riots made
the remark “Newton’s third law – every action has a reaction” to stand mute to
state-sponsored terrorism, an act that was so widely condemned that he was not
sanctioned a US visa for years. (It is a different story now, that he is the PM
and he has so many similarities with Donald Trump, that he is not only granted
the elusive visa (a prized possession for any self-respecting Gujarati) but he
had been given rousing receptions a few times already.
All of them are free and roaming around poisoning the
nation.
In fact, the whole BJP party reads like the ready reckoner
to the vilest assembly of people. Their leaders continuously insult known
icons, historical and contemporary, blatantly flout norms and act as if (they
are right here) they are above law.
There is an Indian saying that goes “Yata Raja, tata Praja”
meaning the people will be like their king, in behavior. BJP is the modern-day
explanation or a case in point to this saying.
The prime minister, a regular on Twitter (not so much like
Donald Trump, but let us say he would measure a 0.65 DT on a Donald trump
Twitter activity scale) who tweets on almost all national and international
events, be it an Oscar win, a cricket match, a wrestler bagging gold, a child
enacting a Babri-Masjid demolition in a school play chooses to keep quiet when
students are targeted and brutalized inside college campuses when the
country’s capital burns when his ministers and the members of the party say
all those atrocious things (Godse was a true patriot, Nehru was a womanizer,
Give me three days and ask the police to look the other way and I will clean
India of Muslims…)
Anti-Muslim:
Unlike the previous three strengths (!) of BJP, this one
needs no elaboration. It is clear. Crystal clear as Jack Nicholson said in A
Few Good Men!
Every single act that they commit, every act they implement,
every step they take is rooted only in one agenda. How to fuck a Muslim. Where
this deep-rooted bigotry stemmed from is no secret. Their ideology is shaped by
the RSS, the parent organization that had called for a Hindu Rashtra even
before independence. What is surprising is that a human being is capable of this
much hatred can be nurtured with apparently no end to the appetite whatsoever.
As some of their party members repeatedly proclaim, “we shall rest only when
the last termite / vermin are thrown out”, probably they would rest only when
India is free of the Muslim population. The catch here is where will be they be
thrown out? To which nation can they possibly go? Thanks to the fundamentalists
who had taken Jihad to a global terror scale and many misplaced brainwashed
morons causing terrible agony the world over, Islamophobia is already an
alarming trend. The catch-22 situation is that they have no place to go. Trust the
BJP to have an answer for every problem. They are building detention centers
across the breadth of the country. I almost cried the other day, when I saw an
interview with an illiterate building worker who was employed in building the
very detention center. He said, “Probably I would end up here when it is finished,
as I have no papers to prove that I am an Indian”. The diabolic NRC would make sure
that the undesirables (throwback to 1930s Germany where the undesirables were the
Jews, Gypsies, Dwarfs, Homosexuals, the communists…) fail the test. The test is
as rigged as a loaded dice. Google “Will you pass the NRC test?” and check for
yourself. Once you fail NRC, you are an illegal immigrant. Enter CAA, the mother
of all acts, through which you are discarded straight away if you are a Muslim,
and your chances are not any to shout from the rooftop, if you are a
non-Muslim.
Simply put, the government can simply decide who can stay
and who will go? If you had been to Auschwitz, you would have seen the notorious
photograph of the German doctor who, with a flick of his hand, sent the
prisoners to the left to the labor camp or to the right to the gas chambers. This
is exactly the same. An exercise of NRC was carried out in Assam, a north-eastern
state with diabolic results. 1.9 million people were left with a tag “illegal
immigrant”.
Watch this wonderful video by journalist Rohini Mohan
I gave up on religion long ago, when what I learned overtook
the indoctrination that had been imbibed, by well-meaning parents, and proudly
embraced rationalism. I refuse to use the term Atheist, as it is coined as an
opposite of a theist, I am not non-somebody. I consider myself a rational human
being trusting no alter-life or heaven with 72 virgins or a purgatory where you
burn forever and after.
BJP made me announce that I do not want to be known as a
Hindu, specifically. The term makes me cringe. Trust me when I tell you, that the
brainwashed are not just the blind Bhakts or the illiterate masses. Educated
people (by education I mean those who have at least graduated, who have access
to materials to read, who can shape an opinion on one’s own intelligence) make
a sizeable portion of the Bhakt world.
If a Jew recalls a history to settle scores, in the present,
with Germans and Arabs, then I do not want to be a Jew.
If a Muslim is going to settle scores with Americans or
Hindus by quoting historical aberrations, I do not want to be a Muslim.
If a Hindu refers to Mughals and, by inference, the Muslims
and kill people and destroy property, I do not want to be a Hindu.
As a citizen of India, I have the right to demand what is
inherently, originally mine. I am asking for that from this bigoted, hate-filled,
venom-spewing BJP
“Give my India back and get the hell out of my country!”
Can feel the pain in your writing, as if you had a dreadful heart ache when you were writing it. Each and every sentence has that feel and a feeling of helplessness and frustration. So the first thing I would remind you is "Karma". Karma will strike back and in time, don't be frustrated.
ReplyDeletevery effectively expressed the irrationality of the arguments of the bhakts, the doublespeak of the leaders and the single point agenda of the party in power--muslimless Bharat. The worst part is BJP won the election at the centre for the second time and with not just more seats but more % of votes. This because of the hatred that has been sown in or the TINA factor or a combination of both can not be said but with as BJP is losing States it seems people now are getting fed up with the hate mongering. To immediately counter this loss of popularity, it was predictable that more oil will be poured in to the fire of hatred, so much so that those who were getting fed up of the hate speeches/ slogans see & feel the hatred & go back to the fold of BJP. Luckily Delhites understood the game better than the Gujaratis and the violence & deaths in Delhi were much less than in 2002 Gujarat. Now it seems The hate brigade has used all the options it had and now there will be a change of strategy. You will see the hate speeches coming down. the ONLY difficulty is India not having any real alternative to the current Leader, only that may save this gang. All in all, the bhakts may not agree, but most Indians have understood the fake nationalism, the futility of hate and while they may not be speaking openly for fear of repercussion, yet the good sense has woken them up and the light at the end of tunnel is visible.
Thanks Uday
DeleteYou are right on every point, as usual.
BJP is in power only because there is no opposition and this is worrying me as India has a history of electing one for state and one for centre. If Congress does not get rid of the Gandhi family and do a serious shake up to come up with a meaningful opposition we are doomed
As Varun Grover mentioned in that speech - BJP will be elected again as "aur option hi kya hai mitron "
Hope Karma settles as you believe
But Karma did not settle Stalin Churchill .....
Remembered the series Chernobyl where the series ended on the following note: truth prevails across religion, political ideology, party lines but the people had to pay a heavy price to learn the truth. Hope it does not come down to that the entire world and in this case India, pay a heavy price to learn the truth. I was always under the impression fron learnings in my childhood and school and otherwise that we all knew the simple truth (that all humans are equal and all religions are equal) but guess ppl have unlearn it already .
ReplyDeleteCue to the tremendous work - Animal farm, "All animals are equal and some animals are more equal than others"
DeleteWhen the party starts with a clear program to be anti-Muslim in everything they do, and keep on feeding the Bhakts the fake narrative to fit the game plan, coupled with the Bhakts being absolute morons and violent thugs, the current situation resembles a powder keg. My worst fear is a cycle of violence, some acts of revenge and another round of escalation and the cycle continues. Modi and Shah must leave if India has to have any future
👍🏽
ReplyDeletethanks - i understand this is one of twitter friends
ReplyDelete